FOS decisions / Residential Mortgage
Residential Mortgage
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
59
Upheld
36
Not upheld
23
Avg redress
£869
Upheld complaints (36)
Nationwide Building Society
DRN-6129252A lender should reasonably anticipate that customers may be upset to receive reminder letters about unpaid balances shortly after confirming mortgage redemption, even if sent by automated systems.
UpheldRedress £50Barclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-5861719A lender must provide clear, complete and accurate information when a customer requests changes to mortgage payment arrangements, and fair redress involves restoring the customer to the position they would have been in had correct informati
UpheldRedress £300Barclays Bank UK Plc
DRN-6150790A lender must provide clear information about mortgage terms and must apply agreed offset arrangements correctly, particularly regarding how interest rate reductions affect payment calculations.
UpheldRedress £350Yorkshire Building Society
DRN-6249520A lender must conduct a full underwriting assessment before definitively stating maximum mortgage terms, rather than applying blanket policy limits without considering individual circumstances.
UpheldBarclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6245653A lender must make a reasonable decision on whether to proceed with a mortgage application based on available information within a reasonable timeframe, rather than leaving the applicant in limbo.
UpheldBank of Scotland plc trading as Halifax
DRN-5997396A lender must apply consent to lease markers to mortgage accounts when agreed, and failure to do so may constitute a breach of the mortgage agreement terms.
UpheldRedress £100Barclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-5741510A lender is liable for the difference in interest rates between loans during a delay period, not for the total interest payments made, as interest would have been charged regardless of which loan was in effect.
UpheldRedress £2,400Furness Building Society
DRN-6130751A lender must clearly communicate changes to mortgage payments and the precise mechanism by which payment adjustments are implemented.
UpheldRedress £745Santander UK Plc
DRN-6086867A lender must carry out a detailed affordability assessment that includes all committed and other expenditure, including costs of properties still owned and mortgaged at the time of the new mortgage completion.
UpheldRedress £300Accord Mortgages Limited
DRN-6086120A lender must communicate with customers in a way that is clear, fair and not misleading, and must take responsibility when a customer reasonably believes they have successfully applied for a new interest rate.
UpheldRedress £500Lloyds Bank PLC
DRN-6250731A financial institution is liable for direct costs caused by its errors but not for speculative losses or costs that would have been incurred regardless.
UpheldPepper (UK) Limited
DRN-6256502A lender must not change mortgage payment calculations in a way that causes underfunding and leaves an outstanding balance at the end of the term without proper notification to the borrower.
UpheldBarclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6146638A mortgage with a flexible credit reserve facility must operate in accordance with its original terms and conditions, including automatic recalculation of contractual monthly payments following payments into or withdrawals from the reserve.
UpheldOneSavings Bank (trading as Kent Reliance)
DRN-6253331A lender should satisfy itself that affordability criteria are met before instructing a valuation, to avoid unnecessary expense to the borrower.
UpheldMasthaven Finance Limited
DRN-5992786A lender must assess mortgage affordability by considering the borrower's ability to repay if circumstances change, including the impact of an expiring first mortgage and by exploring alternative income sources such as sickness benefits.
UpheldShawbrook Bank Limited
DRN-6262623A lender's solicitors must act promptly and proactively to resolve title registration issues that prevent property sales and result in additional borrowing costs.
UpheldSantander UK plc
DRN-6198846A lender must treat a borrower fairly when the mortgage term ends and the borrower cannot immediately repay, including giving adequate warning before instructing solicitors for legal action.
UpheldRedress £500Santander UK Plc
DRN-6162296A lender must provide a consumer with a signed warrant for possession during repossession proceedings.
UpheldBarclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6200825A lender may lawfully pursue debt recovery and repossession proceedings when a mortgage term has ended and the borrower fails to repay the outstanding balance, provided the lender engages fairly with the borrower during the process.
UpheldRedress £250Barclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6130338A lender cannot unilaterally impose mortgage product changes with early repayment charges or extend terms without consent of all borrowers, as this could cause financial detriment to non-consenting parties.
UpheldRedress £300Julian Hodge Bank Limited
DRN-6184104A lender must provide clear, accurate communication about payment arrangements and cannot be held responsible for arrears resulting from a consumer's choice not to complete a required direct debit mandate after initial errors are rectified.
UpheldRedress £300Clydesdale Bank Plc trading as Virgin Money
DRN-6034950A lender must not report a payment as missed or in arrears on a consumer's credit file where the delay resulted from the lender's misleading information and confusion caused during account servicing.
UpheldRedress £100Nationwide Building Society
DRN-6178099Financial compensation for distress and inconvenience caused by a business's errors should be proportionate to the impact and guided by published FOS awards guidance, not designed to punish the business.
UpheldRedress £750TSB Bank plc
DRN-6129523A lender is entitled to make a commercial decision to accept a property warranty falling outside its lending criteria by exception, provided it acts fairly in relation to disclosure and valuation processes.
UpheldRedress £100Clydesdale Bank Plc trading as Virgin Money
DRN-5975366A lender's policy restricting access to beneficial interest rate products for borrowers with consent to let must not breach FCA principles or the Consumer Duty by creating an unfair barrier to refinancing.
UpheldRedress £200HSBC UK Bank Plc
DRN-6219335A lender must fully and fairly consider a consumer's request to switch to a new interest rate product, and cannot arbitrarily refuse such a request without proper consideration.
UpheldBarclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6245588Under the Consumer Duty, a lender must provide clear, timely information about key charges such as early repayment charges and verify customer understanding when interacting one-to-one, particularly where the information prompts a significa
UpheldRedress £8,492Barclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6236192The FOS can only consider complaints about a firm where the complainant has a specified relationship with that firm, and an administrative error in transferring a mortgage security does not create a legal relationship between the parties.
UpheldSantander UK Plc
DRN-5942175A lender cannot continue charging interest on a secured mortgage debt after the secured property has been sold and the debt becomes unsecured.
UpheldHSBC UK Bank Plc
DRN-6147488A lender's solicitor must not amend a signed mortgage deed without first contacting the borrower or their solicitor, as this deprives the borrower of the opportunity to make informed decisions about ancillary costs.
UpheldRedress £450Nationwide Building Society
DRN-6176708A lender must be put into the position they ought to have been in but for the business's error, with compensation reflecting the loss of opportunity caused by the error rather than guaranteeing a successful outcome.
UpheldRedress £500Bank of Scotland plc
DRN-6148613Offset mortgages calculate monthly interest by dividing annual interest by 12 and offset benefits based on actual daily earnings, which may not align perfectly due to varying month lengths, legitimately resulting in occasional payment deman
UpheldBank of Scotland plc
DRN-6133718A lender must not mislead a consumer about the likelihood of mortgage approval, and must make clear when terms are approximate and not guaranteed.
UpheldSantander UK Plc
DRN-5954196A lender is entitled to set its own lending criteria and decline mortgage applications, but must communicate decisions fairly and timeously without providing misleading information.
UpheldRedress £300Nationwide Building Society
DRN-6031212A lender must apply its lending policies fairly and consistently, and cannot impose stricter requirements than its own published policy allows.
UpheldRedress £3,944Santander UK Plc
DRN-4797238A lender must act fairly in enforcing mortgage obligations and must properly account for payments, endowment policy proceeds, and the terms under which a mortgage is held.
Upheld
Not-upheld complaints (23)
Barclays UK Plc
DRN-4183127A lender must treat customers fairly when considering term extension applications, but is not obliged to grant extensions when the borrower has means to repay the debt through alternative means.
Not upheldJun 2022Lloyds Bank PLC
DRN-6149424A lender is entitled to rely on the application form submitted and the stated repayment strategy without conducting detailed verification, provided the strategy is plausible and the borrower is aware of the mortgage type.
Not upheldNational Westminster Bank Public Limited Company
DRN-6233695A lender is not responsible for loss of documents by the DWP when the lender has fulfilled its obligation to send completed forms to the DWP.
Not upheldTopaz Finance Limited
DRN-6128622A mortgage lender is entitled to contact a borrower who remains party to the mortgage account, and service failures must be assessed against what is reasonable in the circumstances.
Not upheldTopaz Finance Limited trading as Bloom Homeloans
DRN-6072606A lender's interest rate is fair if it complies with the contractual terms agreed by the borrower and is applied consistently with changes in the Standard Variable Rate.
Not upheldLloyds Bank PLC
DRN-6256519The ombudsman cannot reconsider complaints that have already been decided unless material new evidence is presented, and the ombudsman may dismiss complaints where no promise of a specific product was demonstrably made.
Not upheldParatus AMC Limited
DRN-6193429A lender is entitled to rely on the professional opinion of a suitably qualified valuer it has instructed and is not responsible for errors made by that valuer.
Not upheldSantander UK Plc
DRN-6159346A lender is entitled to apply its commercial lending criteria to mortgage applications, including porting requests, provided the criteria are applied fairly and consistently.
Not upheldSantander UK Plc
DRN-6149476A lender is entitled to process changes to a jointly-held mortgage on the instruction of one party where it has no actual knowledge of a marital dispute and the terms permit such changes.
Not upheldSantander UK Plc
DRN-6160093Early repayment charges on mortgages are enforceable contractual terms where clearly disclosed and the borrower redeems during a fixed rate period, even if porting is declined.
Not upheldBank of Scotland plc trading as Halifax
DRN-6117339A lender is not liable for delays in providing redemption statements where the underlying cause of delay in mortgage repayment was the borrower's failure to receive endowment policy funds on time, provided the lender makes a fair offer to p
Not upheldCambridge Building Society
DRN-6176438A lender may withdraw a mortgage offer if documentation raises fraud or compliance concerns, even if the error was clerical, provided the lender treats the consumer fairly and proportionately.
Not upheldSantander UK Plc
DRN-6229030A lender may reasonably allow a rate change on a jointly-held mortgage with only one party's consent where the change is beneficial and does not cause financial detriment to the non-consenting party.
Not upheldNationwide Building Society
DRN-6228427A lender must act promptly and communicate effectively when processing mortgage applications, but delays caused by third parties or client-initiated changes do not necessarily constitute service failures warranting additional compensation b
Not upheldSantander UK Plc
DRN-6242464A lender is entitled to rely on self-certified income declarations and need not verify income further at the time of lending, provided affordability calculations show adequate disposable income.
Not upheldNationwide Building Society
DRN-6037598A mortgage lender's valuation is for lending purposes only and the borrower bears responsibility for obtaining their own survey if they wish independent assessment of the property's condition.
Not upheldThe Mortgage Works (UK) Plc
DRN-6209743Early repayment charges can be set as a pre-estimate of loss on a portfolio basis rather than individual calculation, provided terms are clear and transparent.
Not upheldBank of Scotland plc trading as Halifax
DRN-6152212A mortgage lender is entitled to pay service charge arrears on a borrower's behalf to protect its security over the property, and add the cost as an interest-bearing charge to the mortgage account.
Not upheldTopaz Finance Limited trading as Heliodor Mortgages
DRN-6248285A lender cannot accept sole consent to voluntarily surrender a jointly-held mortgage without agreement from both parties, and a court order between borrowers does not alter the lender's contractual obligations or override the need for joint
Not upheldThe Royal Bank of Scotland Plc
DRN-6233852Consumer Duty fair-value assessment obligations do not apply to closed products repaid before the delayed implementation date of 31 July 2024, and complaints about events more than six years prior must be assessed under Section 140A of the
Not upheldBank of Scotland plc
DRN-6058874An early repayment charge (ERC) refund is a discretionary concession, not a contractual term, and a lender is not obliged to lend again even if it has lent before or issued a decision-in-principle.
Not upheldLeeds Building Society
DRN-6177821A lender must provide clear guidance on payment methods when mortgage interest support arrangements begin, but borrowers remain responsible for making their payments.
Not upheldLloyds Bank PLC
DRN-6112113A mortgage lender is not bound by a divorce court order and must apply its own affordability criteria before agreeing to release a co-borrower from a mortgage.
Not upheld