FOS decisions / Professional Indemnity
Professional Indemnity
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
14
Upheld
6
Not upheld
8
Avg redress
£75
Upheld complaints (6)
Aldium Insurance Services Ltd
DRN-5583121An insurance broker has a duty to obtain formal quotes and implement cover amendments in a timely manner when a client has identified the need for increased protection, particularly when circumstances create urgency.
UpheldAldium Insurance Services Ltd
DRN-5583117An insurance broker has a duty to obtain formal quotes for policy amendments when requested by a client, even if the client has not confirmed all details, and must provide those quotes promptly to enable the client to effect cover before a
UpheldARAG Legal Expenses Insurance Company Limited
DRN-6114199A legal expenses insurer may rely on prospects assessments carried out by paralegals supervised by a suitably qualified lawyer with relevant experience in the area of law being considered.
UpheldARAG Legal Expenses Insurance Company Limited
DRN-6210812Legal expenses insurers must deal with claims promptly and fairly, and are entitled to decline cover based on legal advice that a claim lacks reasonable prospects of success.
UpheldRedress £75Markel International Insurance Company Limited
DRN-6220614A liquidation condition in an insurance policy applies only to formal insolvency processes, not to voluntary solvent closures of a business.
UpheldARAG Legal Expenses Insurance Company Limited
DRN-6134841An insurer's initial prospects assessment cost should not be deducted from a policy indemnity limit as it is a claims administration cost necessary to assess cover eligibility, not a legal expense chargeable to the policyholder.
Upheld
Not-upheld complaints (8)
ARAG Legal Expenses Insurance Company
DRN-6263317An insurer may reasonably limit the hourly rate it will pay for a non-panel solicitor if this is clearly stated in the policy terms and alternative suitable options are provided.
Not upheldApr 2026MARSH LIMITED
DRN-6088972An insurance broker is not required to anticipate unprecedented pandemic risks when recommending disease cover that was standard practice for foreseeable diseases like Legionnaires' disease.
Not upheldUK Insurance Limited
DRN-6138611An insurer is not liable for losses caused by a third party's (legal expenses insurer's) conduct, even if the selling insurer made an administrative error in naming the policyholder.
Not upheldARAG Legal Expenses Insurance Company Limited
DRN-6185787An insurer may fairly rely on a clear and unambiguous exclusion clause in a commercial legal expenses insurance policy that excludes cover for disputes arising from agreements entered into before the policy started if the date of occurrence
Not upheldi4me Limited
DRN-5921684An insurance broker is not responsible for an underwriter's subsequent administrative failures in locating policyholder details, provided the policy was properly arranged.
Not upheldArthur J. Gallagher Insurance Brokers Limited
DRN-6209642An insurance broker selling an advised policy must assess the customer's demands and needs and ensure the recommended policy is suitable, with significant exclusions clearly communicated.
Not upheldAmTrust Specialty Limited
DRN-6083119Legal expenses insurance claims are excluded where the insured incident occurred before the policy start date.
Not upheldSoL
DRN-6191972A breach of a condition precedent to liability in an insurance policy permits the insurer to decline cover regardless of whether the breach directly caused the loss.
Not upheld